Crisis in the C-Suite: Confidence or Competence in New Leadership Roles?

It’s a familiar story that plays out in organizations across the globe: a highly skilled and successful team member is promoted to a leadership role, but once they step into their new position, they struggle to adapt. Is this a crisis of confidence or competence? In this blog post, we’ll explore this crucial question and shed light on the challenges faced by leaders transitioning into new roles.

As organizations evolve and industries become more competitive, the demand for effective leadership has never been greater. However, the transition to a leadership role can be fraught with challenges, leaving newly-promoted leaders feeling overwhelmed and ill-equipped for their new responsibilities.

Confidence Crisis

The #1 place for Learning Leaders to learn from each other.

Get the data & knowledge you need to succeed in the era of AI.


We're an invite-only community for L&D leaders to learn from each other through expert-led roundtables, our active forum, and data-driven resources.

Apply to join LHQ

For many leaders, the lack of confidence in their abilities is the primary obstacle to success. The sudden weight of new responsibilities, coupled with the pressure to perform at a high level, can be daunting. As one L&D professional explains, “You go from being an expert in your field to being responsible for a whole team of experts. The fear of failure can be paralyzing.”

To combat this crisis of confidence, organizations must provide support and guidance to new leaders, helping them build the self-assurance needed to excel in their roles.

Competence Crisis

While confidence is a significant factor, many leaders also find themselves lacking the necessary skills to manage their new teams effectively. According to another L&D professional, “You can be a top performer in your field, but that doesn’t automatically make you a great leader. Managing budgets, delegating tasks, and navigating office politics are just a few of the new skills you need to master.”

Organizations must identify the gaps in their leaders’ competencies and provide targeted training to address these deficiencies, ultimately empowering them to excel in their new roles.

The Power of Learning & Development

The key to overcoming both confidence and competence crises lies in effective Learning & Development (L&D) initiatives. By providing new leaders with access to training and resources tailored to their specific needs, organizations can equip them with the skills and confidence required to succeed.

L&D professionals can play a pivotal role in the transition process by creating customized development plans for new leaders, focusing on both hard and soft skills. This holistic approach ensures that leaders are well-rounded and prepared to tackle the diverse challenges they will face in their new roles.

How Learnexus Can Help

For organizations seeking to bridge the gap between confidence and competence for new leaders, Learnexus offers the perfect solution. With a vast network of L&D professionals skilled in leadership development, soft skills training, and other crucial areas, Learnexus streamlines the process of finding and hiring the right talent to address your unique needs.

Not only does Learnexus save organizations 47% in costs, but it also saves managers time and eliminates procurement issues with a single master services agreement, making the process of supporting new leaders as seamless as possible.